Several methods are available for determining the laser beam focal position. They differ in complexity — and consequently in precision and equipment cost. The spread is remarkable: from solutions costing a few euros to direct measurement systems based on complex vision setups costing tens of thousands.
Method 1: Pulsed engraving — the simplest approach
The simplest method involves generating short laser pulses while incrementally increasing the distance between the welding head and the workpiece — typically an anodised aluminium plate. The result is a series of spots or lines of varying diameter or width, depending on the distance at which each pulse was generated. By identifying the spot with the smallest diameter, the operator determines the distance at which the workpiece was positioned at the focal point.
This is an indirect method: it does not measure the beam itself, but the effect the beam produces on the material. Its accuracy is limited for three reasons:
- Thermal effects. The spot size on the plate is significantly larger than the actual laser focal spot diameter.
- Subjectivity. Identifying which spot is smallest is done by visual inspection, and is therefore a matter of operator judgement.
- The Rayleigh effect. To observe any difference in spot diameter at all, pulses must be generated with large spacing between positions along the beam axis — typically 0.5 to 1× the Rayleigh length. In practice this yields spacings of 0.5–1.5 mm or more, which defines the practical accuracy limit of the method.
Accuracy: roughly 0.5–1.5 mm or worse. Cost: a few euros.
Method 2: Direct beam measurement — the high end
At the opposite end of the spectrum are advanced methods for direct beam measurement. These employ precision optical setups with cameras, filters and beam absorbers, enabling observation and measurement of the beam as it is incident directly on the camera sensor.
In such setups, anywhere from several to a dozen or more measurements of the beam diameter are taken at different positions along the beam axis. The results are then approximated to the theoretical beam waist profile described by the Rayleigh model.
Accuracy: better than 10 µm.
The limitations are practical rather than technical. Implementation cost is high, and the measurement requires additional machine space in order to be performed freely. These instruments are designed for permanent installation in the machine, which means a separate unit must be purchased for every machine in the plant.
Cost: up to tens of thousands of euros — per machine.
Method 3: RMA focusfinder.pro — a practical compromise
focusfinder.pro, developed by RMA, sits between the two approaches above.
The method is based on engraving a specially designed pattern — a series of lines — on an appropriately selected material, at multiple positions with different focal offset. Once engraved, the test plate is scanned using a dedicated high-resolution scanner, enabling numerical processing of the resulting image. The acquired data is then approximated and fitted to an ideal Gaussian beam curve, in the same way as in the direct measurement method.
The output is an automatically determined position of the point at which the effective laser beam diameter is at its minimum — the true focal point of the beam.
Because the result comes from numerical data processing rather than visual inspection, the method eliminates subjective assessment by the process engineer or machine operator, while remaining simple to use.
Accuracy: 50–100 µm, and up to 50 µm depending on the configuration of the laser and welding head optics — sufficient to ensure a stable welding process for demanding materials in battery module manufacturing.
Which method should you choose?
| Pulsed engraving | Direct beam measurement | focusfinder.pro | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Measures | Effect on material (indirect) | The beam itself (direct) | Effect on material, numerically processed |
| Accuracy | ~0.5–1.5 mm or more | Better than 10 µm | 50–100 µm (up to 50 µm) |
| Result determined by | Visual inspection | Automatic | Automatic |
| Cost | A few euros | Tens of thousands of euros | Rational implementation cost |
| Machine space | None required | Additional space required | None required |
| Multi-machine use | — | One unit per machine | One unit, multiple machines |
For battery module production — joining bus bars to cells in copper and other difficult-to-weld materials at 250–300 µm thickness — a method with a precision of at least 100–150 µm is required. Anything above 500 µm is insufficiently accurate for this class of joint, which rules out the pulsed engraving approach.
Direct beam measurement clears the accuracy requirement with room to spare, but at a cost and space penalty that has to be repeated for every machine.
The optimal solution, combining high measurement accuracy with a rational implementation cost, is focusfinder.pro.
Based on the technical article “RMA Focus Finder — A Reliable Method for Determining the Focal Point of a Single-Mode Laser” by Rajmund Pobereżny, Project Manager, RMA.
